Call 1-800-229-3258 8:00am - 4:30pm M-F CT
Anderson's It's Elementary
Super Savings!
Enjoy savings up to 78% off Shop Clearance
Poms as low as 85¢
Shop All Poms
New Lower Price and Lower Minimums
on Award Pencils Shop Now
$14.99 Flat Rate Shipping
on all Pins & Lanyards

Award Pencils

Celebrate student success with our fun and colorful Award Pencils—perfect for recognizing attendance, academic achievement, and positive behavior. With a variety of exciting designs and themes, these pencils make everyday rewards meaningful and memorable.

1-40 products of 217

Attendance Pencil - Perfect Attendance Fun Designs

Attendance Pencil - Perfect Attendance Fun Designs

As Low As: $0.37
Student Council Pencil - Torch

Student Council Pencil - Torch

Was: $0.56
Now: $0.17
Fun Pencil - Super Duper Heroes

Fun Pencil - Super Duper Heroes

Was: $0.56
Now: $0.17
School Subject Pencil - Color Block I Love to Write

School Subject Pencil - Color Block I Love to Write

Was: $0.56
Now: $0.12
Happy Birthday Superhero Pencil - Male Teacher

Happy Birthday Superhero Pencil - Male Teacher

Price: $2.09

Happy Birthday Superhero Pencil - Female Teacher

Happy Birthday Superhero Pencil - Female Teacher

Price: $2.09

Holiday Pencils - Shamrocks

Holiday Pencils - Shamrocks

As Low As: $0.37
Paw Pride Pencil - Blue and White Paws

Paw Pride Pencil - Blue and White Paws

As Low As: $0.37
Paw Pride Pencil - Neon Paws

Paw Pride Pencil - Neon Paws

Was: $0.56
Now: $0.17
Paw Print Pencil - Red Holographic Paws

Paw Print Pencil - Red Holographic Paws

As Low As: $0.37
Paw Pride Pencil - Blue Metallic Paws

Paw Pride Pencil - Blue Metallic Paws

As Low As: $0.37
Attendance Pencil - Paint Splatter

Attendance Pencil - Paint Splatter

As Low As: $0.37
Paw Pride Pencil - Black and White Paws

Paw Pride Pencil - Black and White Paws

Was: $0.56
Now: $0.37
Sharpened Test Taking Pencil - Do Your Best Red Sparkle

Sharpened Test Taking Pencil - Do Your Best Red Sparkle

Was: $0.56
As Low As: $0.37
Sharpened Test Taking Pencil - Do Your Best On the Test Splatter Paint

Sharpened Test Taking Pencil - Do Your Best On the Test Splatter Paint

As Low As: $0.37
Birthday Pencil - Birthday Bash

Birthday Pencil - Birthday Bash

As Low As: $0.37
Birthday Pencil - Party Time Happy Birthday

Birthday Pencil - Party Time Happy Birthday

Was: $0.56
Now: $0.12
School Subject Pencil - Shooting Star Math

School Subject Pencil - Shooting Star Math

Was: $0.49
As Low As: $0.37
Motivational Pencil - Student of the Month Hand Prints

Motivational Pencil - Student of the Month Hand Prints

As Low As: $0.37
Motivational Pencil - Holographic Student of the Month

Motivational Pencil - Holographic Student of the Month

As Low As: $0.37
Citizenship Pencil - Good Citizenship Stars and Arches

Citizenship Pencil - Good Citizenship Stars and Arches

As Low As: $0.37
School Pencil - Do Your Best On the Test Silver Shine

School Pencil - Do Your Best On the Test Silver Shine

Was: $0.49
As Low As: $0.37
Grade Level Pencil - Fascinating 5th Grader

Grade Level Pencil - Fascinating 5th Grader

Was: $0.56
Now: $0.19
Grade Level Pencil - Fabulous 4th Grader

Grade Level Pencil - Fabulous 4th Grader

Was: $0.56
Now: $0.19
Grade Level Pencil - Terrific 3rd Grader

Grade Level Pencil - Terrific 3rd Grader

Was: $0.56
Now: $0.19
Citizenship Pencil - Outstanding Citizenship Patriotic Stars

Citizenship Pencil - Outstanding Citizenship Patriotic Stars

As Low As: $0.37
Attendance Pencil - Excellent Attendance Paw Prints

Attendance Pencil - Excellent Attendance Paw Prints

As Low As: $0.37
Birthday Pencil - Holographic Swirl Happy Birthday From Your Principal

Birthday Pencil - Holographic Swirl Happy Birthday From Your Principal

As Low As: $0.37
Attendance Pencil - Perfect Attendance Rainbow Mosaic

Attendance Pencil - Perfect Attendance Rainbow Mosaic

As Low As: $0.37
Birthday Pencil - Paw Print Happy Birthday

Birthday Pencil - Paw Print Happy Birthday

As Low As: $0.37
Birthday Pencil - Rainbow Happy Birthday

Birthday Pencil - Rainbow Happy Birthday

As Low As: $0.37
Motivational Pencil - Student of the Month Holographic Paws

Motivational Pencil - Student of the Month Holographic Paws

As Low As: $0.37
Character Pencil - Caught Being Good Sparkle

Character Pencil - Caught Being Good Sparkle

As Low As: $0.37
Honor Roll Pencil - Ribbon Glitz

Honor Roll Pencil - Ribbon Glitz

As Low As: $0.37
Birthday Pencil - Happy Birthday From Your Principal Balloons

Birthday Pencil - Happy Birthday From Your Principal Balloons

As Low As: $0.37
Attendance Pencil - Colored Holographic Stars

Attendance Pencil - Colored Holographic Stars

Was: $0.56
Now: $0.21
Reading Pencil - Holographic I Read To the Principal

Reading Pencil - Holographic I Read To the Principal

As Low As: $0.37
Motivational Pencil - Believe, Achieve, Succeed

Motivational Pencil - Believe, Achieve, Succeed

As Low As: $0.37
School Subject Pencil - Math Star With White Stars

School Subject Pencil - Math Star With White Stars

Was: $0.56
Now: $0.19
School Subject Pencil - Writing Is Awesome Holographic Rainbow

School Subject Pencil - Writing Is Awesome Holographic Rainbow

Was: $0.56
Now: $0.21

Trending Products

PreviousNext