Anderson's It's Elementary
Super Savings!
Enjoy savings up to 82% off Shop Clearance
Poms as low as 85¢
Shop All Poms
Save 15% on your first order
When you sign up to receive Emails Sign Up Now
Free Sample Kit
See and Feel our Product Request Now

Award Pencils

Celebrate student success with our fun and colorful Award Pencils—perfect for recognizing attendance, academic achievement, and positive behavior. With a variety of exciting designs and themes, these pencils make everyday rewards meaningful and memorable.

1-40 products of 212

Motivational Pencil - Holographic Student of the Month

Motivational Pencil - Holographic Student of the Month

As Low As: $0.42
Honor Roll Pencil - Principal's Honor Roll

Honor Roll Pencil - Principal's Honor Roll

As Low As: $0.42
Birthday Pencil - Party Time Happy Birthday

Birthday Pencil - Party Time Happy Birthday

Was: $0.56
Now: $0.19
Smencils® Scented Pencils - Sweetheart

Smencils® Scented Pencils - Sweetheart

Price: $69.99

Smencils® Scented Pencils Tub - Soda Pop

Smencils® Scented Pencils Tub - Soda Pop

Price: $69.99

Happy Birthday Superhero Pencil - Male Teacher

Happy Birthday Superhero Pencil - Male Teacher

Price: $2.09

Happy Birthday Superhero Pencil - Female Teacher

Happy Birthday Superhero Pencil - Female Teacher

Price: $2.09

Smencils® Scented Pencils - Safari

Smencils® Scented Pencils - Safari

Price: $69.99

Holiday Pencils - Shamrocks

Holiday Pencils - Shamrocks

As Low As: $0.41
Attendance Pencil - Paint Splatter

Attendance Pencil - Paint Splatter

As Low As: $0.42
Sharpened Test Taking Pencil - Do Your Best Red Sparkle

Sharpened Test Taking Pencil - Do Your Best Red Sparkle

As Low As: $0.42
Sharpened Test Taking Pencil - Do Your Best On the Test Splatter Paint

Sharpened Test Taking Pencil - Do Your Best On the Test Splatter Paint

As Low As: $0.42
Attendance Pencil - Perfect Attendance Fun Designs

Attendance Pencil - Perfect Attendance Fun Designs

As Low As: $0.42
Birthday Pencil - Birthday Bash

Birthday Pencil - Birthday Bash

As Low As: $0.48
School Subject Pencil - Shooting Star Math

School Subject Pencil - Shooting Star Math

Was: $2.54
As Low As: $0.48
Honor Roll Pencil - Outstanding Effort Color Block

Honor Roll Pencil - Outstanding Effort Color Block

As Low As: $0.48
Motivational Pencil - Student of the Month Hand Prints

Motivational Pencil - Student of the Month Hand Prints

As Low As: $0.48
Citizenship Pencil - Good Citizenship Stars and Arches

Citizenship Pencil - Good Citizenship Stars and Arches

As Low As: $0.48
School Pencil - Do Your Best On the Test Silver Shine

School Pencil - Do Your Best On the Test Silver Shine

Was: $0.49
As Low As: $0.31
Grade Level Pencil - Fascinating 5th Grader

Grade Level Pencil - Fascinating 5th Grader

Was: $0.56
Now: $0.19
Grade Level Pencil - Fabulous 4th Grader

Grade Level Pencil - Fabulous 4th Grader

Was: $0.56
Now: $0.19
Grade Level Pencil - Terrific 3rd Grader

Grade Level Pencil - Terrific 3rd Grader

Was: $0.56
Now: $0.19
Citizenship Pencil - Outstanding Citizenship Patriotic Stars

Citizenship Pencil - Outstanding Citizenship Patriotic Stars

As Low As: $0.42
Attendance Pencil - Excellent Attendance Paw Prints

Attendance Pencil - Excellent Attendance Paw Prints

As Low As: $0.42
Birthday Pencil - Holographic Swirl Happy Birthday From Your Principal

Birthday Pencil - Holographic Swirl Happy Birthday From Your Principal

As Low As: $0.48
Attendance Pencil - Perfect Attendance Rainbow Mosaic

Attendance Pencil - Perfect Attendance Rainbow Mosaic

As Low As: $0.42
Birthday Pencil - Paw Print Happy Birthday

Birthday Pencil - Paw Print Happy Birthday

As Low As: $0.48
Birthday Pencil - Rainbow Happy Birthday

Birthday Pencil - Rainbow Happy Birthday

As Low As: $0.48
Motivational Pencil - Student of the Month Holographic Paws

Motivational Pencil - Student of the Month Holographic Paws

As Low As: $0.42
Character Pencil - Caught Being Good Sparkle

Character Pencil - Caught Being Good Sparkle

As Low As: $0.48
Stars Honor Roll Pencil

Stars Honor Roll Pencil

Was: $0.56
Now: $0.19
Honor Roll Pencil - Ribbon Glitz

Honor Roll Pencil - Ribbon Glitz

As Low As: $0.48
Honor Roll Pencil - Wave Glitz

Honor Roll Pencil - Wave Glitz

As Low As: $0.48
Birthday Pencil - Happy Birthday From Your Principal Balloons

Birthday Pencil - Happy Birthday From Your Principal Balloons

As Low As: $0.42
Attendance Pencil - Colored Holographic Stars

Attendance Pencil - Colored Holographic Stars

As Low As: $0.48
Reading Pencil - Holographic I Read To the Principal

Reading Pencil - Holographic I Read To the Principal

As Low As: $0.48
Motivational Pencil - Believe, Achieve, Succeed

Motivational Pencil - Believe, Achieve, Succeed

As Low As: $0.48
School Subject Pencil - Math Star With White Stars

School Subject Pencil - Math Star With White Stars

Was: $0.56
Now: $0.19
School Subject Pencil - Writing Is Awesome Holographic Rainbow

School Subject Pencil - Writing Is Awesome Holographic Rainbow

As Low As: $0.48
Reading Pencil - Pawsome Reader

Reading Pencil - Pawsome Reader

As Low As: $0.42

Trending Products

PreviousNext